Mental Illness and Crim Behavior

A study done in 1999 shows that forbidden of the three m macabreion arrests made, we can rule that no specific flow, sparing group, or gender group is the cause for much(prenominal) a high number of arrests. In the reading it seems as if execr satisf strikeory de conveyor is spoken ab kayoed as a means to satisfy ones needs in order to make up for something that they lack. For example in the reading it explains how young adults argon a lot frustrated with their lives regardless of race or economic status, they will dumbfound a mode to take their frustrations and cilium fall out.This is to say that no event how form or bizarre the shepherds crooks mind seems to be, the sorry still has learning and attention to detail of the offense they tolerate been involved in and so they can non be claimed as intellectually ill. distant to these findings, one might argue that until now though evil is non inescapably a race or economic factor however it does play a role in o nes life (environmental factors).In general it is cognize that criminal expression is both an scale-by-case and sociable problem. Some crimes atomic number 18 plan and carried out while former(a)s seem much of a compulsive act. Either appearance, these crimes look at logic and self-control, as it says in the reading. (Page 26) This reading further suggests that no matter how out of the norm a criminal act mat be, the offender has a complete encountering and awareness of the crime and their actions that go along with carrying out the crime.This defeats the groundings of the mania or the mentally ill but guilty defense. However, after looking cover version end at the reading, one whitethorn interrogate the statements made because they seem to one sided in that they are not exploring the idea of a criminal who is mentally ill and effective exploring the idea that society is the cause of criminal acts. One statement that is made which stands out is when it is said that c rime is not patrimonial like the chicken pox. trance it stands true that just because one person in a community decides to meet in criminal behavior, it does not mean to say that others will soon demoralise to engage in similar behavior simply because they are close to that initial person. However, when it comes to people who are mentally ill the crimes they commit are a fiber of chicken pox in that certain(p) mental indispositiones cause certain types of crimes so that it is sometimes detectable based on ones behavior if they are going to commit a crime linked to their mental sickness.Also, if a criminal with a mental illness is get into the general population of a correctional facility, they may be influenced by others and their behavior to act in a way similar to those they had contact with. Although the environment of a person often determines their behavior, logic, and emotions their DNA or pre-disposed conditions also play a role. Referring back to the example given o n foliate 27, a man who murdered his married woman in the heat of an argument would not be considered for the insanity defense because of his temporary worker insanity through a scarlet crime of passion.To Samenow, this person was not seized by an alien or had an uncontrollable nerve impulse and so this man was not out of character for committing this crime because according to Samenow he had voiced in the past that he had wished her dead or that the man often held vendettas a raisest those who crossed him. Samenow then shows a case in which a man with worse problems (his wife cheating on him), did not seek revenge in this way and chose to act rationally by petitioning for a divorce.According to Samenow the first case exhibits a man not with a mental illness but with a social/personal problem whose environment forces him to contract to act in much(prenominal) a way. Although compelling it can be argued that this quite is an example of a man who is able to portray or mimic wha t the norm is and can appear to be function normally despite having there be a severe mental illness such as a re ensnareation disorder in which he engages in purposeful malicious behavior (pushing his wife, seeking revenge for those who harm him) and may actually be more harm to himself than others forward murdering his wife.This person may be super charming, intelligent, and able to be very put together meanwhile internally he cannot cope with the environment around him and so he creates this persona of the person who others persuade him to be. This is a person who suffers from a major(ip) mental illness and will not be able to emotionally understand their crimes or the logic/morality for why it is wrong. Although having a mental illness may for an individual to act in a certain way, it does not excuse their actions and they should prolong consequences just as any other person would.However, a person with a mental illness should be held to a different level of responsibilit y since they already cannot cope with their lives which is why they acted in such a way to begin with. A criminal with a mental illness should be put into therapy to allow them to gain techniques to cope with life and with situations which cause them to act out along with an incarceration sentence.